Challenges and Setbacks in UN Environmental Summits 2024

Four key UN summits on biodiversity (Colombia), climate (Azerbaijan), land degradation (Saudi Arabia), and plastics (South Korea) failed to deliver meaningful outcomes.

Table of Contents

Despite participation from governments, researchers, industries, and civil society organizations, these summits achieved partial or no success. This marks the fourth consecutive instance of unsatisfactory outcomes in UN discussions addressing biodiversity loss, climate change, and plastic pollution.

Key Challenges and Setbacks

Divergent National Interests
- Developing Nations: Demand for increased technology transfer and financial support.
  - Struggle with economic constraints, climate impacts, and developmental challenges.
- Developed Nations: Reluctance to commit more resources due to domestic political and economic pressures.
- Examples:
  - Colombia Summit: Gridlock over financing sustainable land-use practices.
    - $700 billion-a-year requirement for conservation remains unmet.
  - Azerbaijan Summit: Developing nations demanded $1.3 trillion annually; only vague commitments were made.
    - Divisions over transitioning from fossil fuels.
  - South Korea Summit: Opposition to a legally binding treaty on plastics by nations reliant on plastics-driven economies.
Consensus and Framework Issues: Disagreements on frameworks to monitor and enforce goals:
- Azerbaijan: Divisions on accountability mechanisms for emission reductions.
- Saudi Arabia: Industrialized nations and African countries clashed over a legally binding drought protocol.
  - African nations sought concrete economic commitments; industrialized nations preferred a broad framework.
- Impact of Global Crises: COVID-19, economic instability, and geopolitical conflicts diverted attention and resources:
  - Public health, economic recovery, and social stability became priorities over environmental action.
  - Developing economies faced added challenges of inflation, debt, and climate vulnerabilities.

Implications of Failures

Delayed Action: Critical measures for biodiversity loss, climate change, land degradation, and plastic pollution postponed.
- Risk of reaching irreversible environmental tipping points.

Interlinked Environmental Crises

Climate Change and Biodiversity Loss: Climate change accelerates habitat destruction, exacerbating biodiversity loss.
- Degraded ecosystems release carbon, worsening global warming.
Plastic Pollution: Harms ecosystems and contributes to greenhouse gas emissions during production and degradation.

Fragmented Efforts: Unilateral regional actions could replace multilateral initiatives.
- Lack of global coherence risks creating new problems.
Erosion of Trust: Repeated failures undermine confidence, complicating future negotiations.
Increased Pressure on Future Summits: Upcoming summits face higher expectations for delivering significant outcomes.

Strategies for Rebuilding Momentum

Climate Finance: Developed nations must fulfill financial and technological commitments to developing nations.
- Helps bridge trust gaps and fosters equitable negotiations.
Enhanced Transparency and Accountability: Establish robust mechanisms to monitor progress and hold nations accountable.
- Builds confidence in multilateral processes.
Inclusive Diplomacy: Address geopolitical tensions.
- Ensure vulnerable nations’ voices are heard for equitable participation.
Focus on Implementation: Shift emphasis from ambitious pledges to measurable, tangible actions.
Integrated Strategies: Address interconnections among biodiversity loss, land degradation, plastic pollution, and climate change.
- Promote ecosystem protection, landscape restoration, and pollution reduction while tackling global warming.