Editorial of the Day (21st Aug): Social Justice- Scheduled Caste sub-classification

Context

• The Supreme Court’s recent decision on sub-classification within the reservation for Scheduled Castes (SC) and Scheduled Tribes (ST) has sparked significant debate within the Dalit community.
• The decision allows for sub-classification, which aims to address the demands of those SC/ST communities that have not fully benefited from the existing reservation system.

Need for Sub-Classification in Scheduled Castes

• Certain communities like the Mahadalits, Valmiki, Mazhabi Samaj, Musahars, Madigas, Chakkiliyans, and Arunthathiyars have been unable to fully benefit from the existing reservation system due to various historical and social factors.
• B.R. Ambedkar advocated for a separate share system for Dalits, recognizing the diverse needs and experiences within the community.

Criticism from Dominant Sections

• Fear of Dilution: Dominant sections within SCs have opposed sub-classification, fearing that it will dilute their share of reservation benefits.
• Betrayal of Slogan: The slogan “Jiski jitni sankhya bhaari utni uski hissedari” (The larger the population, the greater the share) has been exposed as a hollow promise by the actions of those who have benefited from reservation but resisted sub-classification.

The Importance of Sub-Classification

• Ensuring Participation: Sub-classification is essential to ensure that all sections within the SC and ST communities have equal opportunities to participate in the benefits of reservation.
• Addressing Historical Injustices: Sub-classification can help address historical inequalities and provide a more equitable distribution of resources.
• Strengthening Dalit Unity: Contrary to fears, sub-classification can actually strengthen Dalit unity by ensuring that all members of the community feel included and represented.

Conclusion

The debate over sub-classification within reservation for SCs and STs is a complex one, with valid arguments on both sides. While some may fear that it will undermine Dalit unity, it is essential to recognize that it is a necessary step to ensure that all members of the community have equal opportunities to benefit from reservation policies. By addressing historical inequalities and promoting inclusivity, sub-classification can strengthen Dalit unity in the long run.

Sharing is caring!