Non Market Economy, Criteria, Implications and Impact

A Non Market Economy (NME) country operates without market principles of cost or pricing structures, often resulting in sales that do not reflect the true value of a product.

Table of Contents

Context:

Vietnam wants the United States to change its designation as a “non-market economy” to a “market economy.”
This change would help Vietnam reduce the high tariffs placed on its goods imported into the US.

Overview of Non Market Economy Status

A nonmarket economy (NME) country operates without market principles of cost or pricing structures, often resulting in sales that do not reflect the true value of a product.

Criteria for Nonmarket Economy Designation by the United States

Currency Convertibility: Assessment of whether the country’s currency is freely exchangeable in the international market.
Wage Negotiation: Evaluation of whether wage rates are determined through free bargaining between labour and management.
Foreign Investment: Consideration of the degree to which foreign investments and joint ventures are allowed.
Government Role: Analysis of whether the government owns or controls the means of production.
Resource Allocation: Review of whether the state controls the allocation of resources and decisions regarding price and output.

Implications of Non Market Economy Status

Anti-Dumping Duties: Being labelled a non-market economy allows the U.S. to impose anti-dumping duties on goods from these countries.

These duties are calculated based on the price differences between the export price and what the goods would cost in a third-party market economy (e.g., Bangladesh).
This method often does not take into account the actual production costs in the non-market economy, potentially inflating the duties imposed.

Impact of Non Market Economy Status

Trade Barriers: Leads to the implementation of strict regulations and trade barriers.
Investment Climate: Can negatively affect the investment climate of the designated country.
Diplomatic Strain: May strain political and diplomatic relations between the NME country and the U.S.
Competitiveness: Undermines the competitiveness of the NME country’s exports by imposing higher costs on goods entering the U.S.

Vietnam’s Current Economic Classification

Vietnam is classified by the U.S. as a non-market economy, a designation it shares with 12 other countries, including Russia, China, and former Soviet states.
This classification has been in place for over two decades despite Vietnam becoming one of the top trading partners of the U.S. and playing a strategic role in countering China’s influence in the region.

Vietnam’s Push for Market Economy Status

Economic Reforms: Vietnam claimed it has made significant economic reforms that justify a change in status.
- According to the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), Vietnam now permits foreign investments, and wage rates are set through negotiation rather than state control. Most production means are also not state-owned.
Benefits of Reclassification: Achieving market economy status would help Vietnam eliminate the punitive anti-dumping duties, making its exports more competitive in the U.S. market.
- The Center for WTO and International Trade in Vietnam argues that the current method for calculating these duties unfairly elevates the dumping margins, not reflecting the actual costs for Vietnamese companies.

Challenges to Vietnam’s Reclassification

Opposition from U.S. Industries: U.S. steelmakers and the American Shrimp Processors Association oppose the reclassification, citing Vietnam’s remaining restrictions on land ownership and weak labour laws. They argue that lower duties on Vietnamese shrimp would adversely affect U.S. industries.
Political Resistance: Some U.S. lawmakers express concerns that reclassifying Vietnam could inadvertently benefit Chinese state firms that have substantial investments in Vietnam, potentially allowing them to bypass U.S. tariffs more easily.