Home   »   Daily Current Affairs For UPSC 2025   »   Delhi's Mahila Samman Yojna

Delhi’s Mahila Samman Yojna, Cash Transfer Policy

What are the Arguments For and Against the Cash Transfer Policy?

Aspect Arguments For Arguments Against
Fiscal Impact ●       Provides immediate financial relief to vulnerable populations.

●       Boosts purchasing power and stimulates local economies.

●       Imposes a significant fiscal burden, diverting funds from long-term investments like infrastructure and healthcare.

●       May lead to underfunding of critical public services like education and sanitation.

Dependency Acts as a safety net for households without stable incomes. ●       Risks creating a culture of dependency, discouraging employment and entrepreneurial efforts.

●       May undermine work ethic and skill development.

Inflationary Pressures Increases demand, potentially spurring economic growth. Could lead to localized inflation and erode the purchasing power of cash transfers.
Addressing Socio-Economic Issues ●       Directly tackles immediate challenges like poverty and unemployment.

●       Promotes social equity by targeting marginalized groups.

●       Offers short-term relief but fails to address structural issues like lack of quality education or job creation.

●       May oversimplify complex socio-economic problems requiring deeper policy interventions.

Risk of Misuse Empirical evidence shows recipients typically spend transfers on essentials like nutrition and education. ●       Unconditional transfers might be misused on non-essentials or harmful activities (e.g., alcohol, gambling).

●       Risk of inefficiency in implementation or beneficiary identification.

Electoral and Political Impact ●       Demonstrates responsiveness to public needs and fulfills electoral promises.

●       Enhances political legitimacy and accountability.

●       Often introduced close to elections, seen as populist measures aimed at securing votes.

●       Focus on short-term political gains over long-term stability and growth.

Equity ●       Helps build financial independence for women, promoting gender equality.

●       Supports inclusive growth for marginalized and disadvantaged communities.

●       Unconditional transfers might not be targeted effectively, benefitting non-deserving individuals.

●       Universal schemes risk spreading resources too thin to make a substantial impact.

Economic Opportunity Costs Provides immediate economic stimulus by boosting consumption. Diverts resources from alternative investments with higher long-term returns, like skill development.
Sustainability ●       Leverages existing digital infrastructure for efficient implementation (e.g., DBT).

●       Ensures transparency and minimizes leakages by bypassing middlemen.

●       Poses long-term sustainability issues without clear exit strategies or sustainable revenue sources.

●       May lead to socio-political backlash if phased out.

Sharing is caring!

About the Author

I, Sakshi Gupta, am a content writer to empower students aiming for UPSC, PSC, and other competitive exams. My objective is to provide clear, concise, and informative content that caters to your exam preparation needs. I strive to make my content not only informative but also engaging, keeping you motivated throughout your journey!