Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), Functions, Challenges

The Supreme Court held as maintainable the West Bengal government’s suit challenging the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) actions.

• West Bengal government accused the Union government of constitutional overreach for using the CBI to investigate in the state despite the withdrawal of general consent on November 16, 2018
• The Centre argued the suit was not maintainable as the CBI is an independent agency.

The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) is India’s primary domestic crime investigation agency. The CBI was established in 1963 by the Government of India to investigate serious crimes, including corruption, fraud, and social crimes. The CBI also guides police forces across the country in the fight against corruption.

Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI)

CBI Historical Background

• The Delhi Special Police Establishment Act of 1946, enacted by Parliament, aimed to establish a specialized investigative body, the CBI.
• In 1963, the Indian government established the Central Bureau of Investigation through a resolution.
• The Santhanam Committee, focusing on corruption prevention, is associated with the CBI.
• The resolution outlines the specific categories of cases that fall under the purview of the CBI.

Legal Status of CBI

• The CBI is not a statutory body, as it was set up by a resolution (1963) of the Ministry of Home Affairs
• It derives its power to investigate from the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, of 1946.
• CBI also coordinates international investigations on behalf of Interpol member countries.

We’re now on WhatsApp. Click to Join

Appointment of Central Bureau of Investigation Director

The Director of the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) is appointed through a process outlined in Section 4A of the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act of 1946. This act, however, has been revised by the Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act (2013).

• Selection Committee:
  • The selection committee, responsible for suggesting the appointment of the CBI Director, is chaired by the Prime Minister.
  • Other members of the committee include the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha and the Chief Justice of India or a Supreme Court Judge nominated by the Chief Justice.
• Tenure of the CBI Director:
  • The CBI Director is appointed for a minimum term of two years from the date of assuming office.

Division of Central Bureau of Investigation

The CBI is organized into various divisions to handle specific types of cases, ensuring specialization and efficiency.

Functions of Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI)

• Legal Basis: Operates under the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, 1946; not a statutory body.
• Supervision: Works under the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) for matters related to the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
• Preventing Corruption: Key role in preventing corruption and maintaining integrity in government administration.
• Economic and Fiscal Laws: Investigates cases related to infringement of economic and fiscal laws, such as customs, central excise, income tax, etc.
• Jurisdiction: Takes up cases concerning economic laws either upon request from the concerned department or in consultation with them.
• Serious Crimes: Investigates serious crimes with national and international implications, particularly those committed by professional criminals or organized gangs.
• Coordination: Coordinates activities among state police forces and anti-corruption agencies.
• Public Importance: Can, at the request of a state government, take up and investigate cases of public importance.
• Crime Statistics: Maintains crime statistics and disseminates criminal information.
• International Representation: Serves as India’s representative for correspondence with INTERPOL.

Cases Handled by CBI

• Anti-Corruption: The CBI investigates corruption cases under the Prevention of Corruption Act involving public officials, central government employees, and entities controlled by the central government.
• Economic Crimes: It addresses significant financial scams and serious economic frauds, including those related to counterfeit currency, bank fraud, cybercrime, and smuggling.
• Suo Moto Cases: The CBI prioritises investigations in Union Territories and can undertake probes in state territories with permission from the central government or mandates from the judiciary.
• Special Crimes: The CBI also investigates severe, organised crimes like terrorism, bomb blasts, and crimes involving the mafia or underworld, upon requests from state governments or directives from higher courts.

Challenges Before CBI

• Lack of Autonomy:
  • Challenge: Political interference in CBI’s functioning.
  • Implication: Threatens the agency’s independence and impartiality.
• Resource Constraint:
  • Challenge: Inadequate infrastructure, manpower, and modern equipment.
  • Implication: Hinders efficiency and effectiveness in conducting investigations.
• Questionable Methods:
  • Challenge: Concerns about questionable procurement of evidence and officers deviating from established procedures.
  • Implication: Raises ethical and legal issues, impacting the credibility of investigations.
• Legal Limitations:
  • Challenge: Operating under outdated legislation, leading to jurisdictional ambiguity, lack of transparency, and inadequate accountability mechanisms.
  • Implication: Hinders the CBI’s ability to address contemporary challenges and maintain public trust.
• Procedural Delays:
  • Challenge: Lengthy legal procedures, delays in obtaining search warrants, recording statements, and presenting evidence in court.
  • Implication: Slows down investigations, making it difficult to secure timely convictions and justice.

Need for Institutional Reforms in CBI

• Independence and Autonomy:
  • Establish the CBI as an independent investigative agency, separate from administrative control.
  • Ensure functional autonomy for investigations, free from political or bureaucratic influences.
  • Strengthen legal provisions to safeguard autonomy and impartiality.
• Jurisdiction and Coordination:
  • Clarify jurisdictional boundaries to prevent conflicts with state police forces.
  • Enhance coordination and collaboration with state agencies for smoother investigations.
• Legal Framework:
  • Review and update laws to enhance investigative powers.
  • Provide statutory backing for investigative techniques.
  • Streamline legal procedures to expedite investigations and trials.
• Technological Upgradation:
  • Invest in advanced technology for digital forensics, data analysis, and crime mapping.
  • Upgrade infrastructure to equip the CBI with modern investigative tools.

Supreme Court Observations on CBI

Way Forward

• Autonomy and Independence:
  • Strengthen legal provisions for CBI’s independence.
  • Establish CBI as an autonomous investigative agency.
• Legal Reforms:
  • Update laws to address jurisdictional issues.
  • Provide statutory backing for modern investigative techniques.
• Jurisdiction and Coordination:
  • Clarify jurisdiction to avoid conflicts with state forces.
  • Enhance coordination with state agencies for efficient investigations.
• Technological Upgradation:
  • Invest in advanced technology for digital forensics.
  • Upgrade infrastructure for modern investigative tools.
• Resource Allocation:
  • Address resource constraints for manpower and equipment.
  • Ensure a sufficient budget for operational needs.
• Ethical Standards:
  • Enforce ethical guidelines for evidence procurement.
  • Conduct regular training on ethical standards.
• Public Outreach and Transparency:
  • Increase transparency in ongoing investigations.
  • Foster public trust through outreach programs.
• International Collaboration:
  • Strengthen collaborations with global law enforcement.
  • Leverage international expertise in transnational cases.
• Continuous Evaluation and Improvement:
  • Establish mechanisms for periodic performance evaluation.
  • Embrace a culture of continuous learning and adaptation.
• Legislative Oversight:
  • Establish robust legislative oversight to ensure accountability.
  • Prevent undue interference in CBI’s activities.

Sharing is caring!