How Beggar-Thy-Neighbour Policies can Make Global Trade?

Beggar-thy-neighbour policies are economic strategies employed by a country with the goal of improving its own economic conditions at the expense of other nations. These protectionist measures generally lead to conflicts, such as trade wars or currency devaluations, which can have both short-term and long-term consequences for global trade and inter-country relations.

Common Examples of Beggar-Thy-Neighbour Policies

1. Trade Wars:
   • Definition: Countries impose heavy tariffs and strict import quotas on foreign goods to shield domestic industries from foreign competition.
   • Impact: This reduces the inflow of foreign goods, protecting local producers but also increasing the cost of imported products for consumers.
2. Currency Wars:
   • Definition: Central banks devalue or depreciate the domestic currency, making exports cheaper and imports more expensive.
   • Impact: By weakening the value of their currency, countries make their goods and services more competitive in the global market while reducing foreign imports.

Origin of the Term

• The term “Beggar-thy-neighbour” was first coined by the renowned economist Adam Smith in his 1776 work The Wealth of Nations. Smith used this phrase to describe policies where one nation’s actions to improve its own economic standing could negatively impact the economy of its trading partners.

Arguments in Favor of Beggar-Thy-Neighbour Policies

1. Protection of Domestic Industries:
   • Infant Industries Protection: Young or developing industries often lack the scale and financial resources to compete with established foreign competitors. Protectionist policies can give them the breathing room they need to grow and mature.
   • Example: Many countries, particularly in the developing world, use trade barriers to protect emerging industries from more established global players.
2. Boosting Exports and Reducing Imports:
   • Currency Depreciation: When a country devalues its currency, it makes its products cheaper in foreign markets, thus promoting exports.
   • Increased Export Demand: At the same time, foreign goods become more expensive, which reduces imports.
   • Example: A weaker domestic currency often results in more competitive pricing for goods and services abroad, thereby increasing export volume.
3. Trade Surplus:
   • Higher Exports, Fewer Imports: The combined effect of higher exports and reduced imports can lead to a trade surplus, which is often seen as beneficial for the country’s balance of payments.
   • Example: Countries with a consistent trade surplus can strengthen their foreign exchange reserves, further improving their economic standing.

Criticism of Beggar-Thy-Neighbour Policies

1. Triggers Retaliatory Actions:
   • Trade Wars: When one country imposes tariffs or devalues its currency, others often retaliate with similar measures, leading to a cycle of escalating tariffs and counter-tariffs. This results in trade wars that harm global trade.
   • Example: The trade war between the U.S. and China, where both countries imposed tariffs on each other’s goods, disrupted international trade and caused economic harm to both parties.
2. Harmful to Consumers:
   • Increased Prices: Higher tariffs on imports make foreign goods more expensive, leading to higher prices for consumers, particularly on essential goods that cannot be easily produced domestically.
   • Example: Increases in tariffs on Chinese electronics have led to higher prices for consumers in the U.S. and other nations, reducing their purchasing power.
3. Long-Term Economic Consequences:
   • Reduced Global Growth: The cumulative effect of trade wars and protectionism can lead to a reduction in global economic growth. By limiting trade, countries also limit opportunities for foreign investment, innovation, and cross-border partnerships.
   • Example: A sustained period of protectionism can cause global supply chains to break down, reducing overall efficiency in the world economy.
4. Distortion of Comparative Advantage:
   • Inefficiency: By implementing protectionist policies, countries may continue producing goods inefficiently, diverting resources from areas where they have a comparative advantage. This can result in a net loss in global productivity.
   • Example: Countries may subsidize failing industries that would be more efficient if left to market forces, causing an artificial misallocation of resources.

Conclusion

Beggar-thy-neighbour policies may offer short-term benefits for the country implementing them, but they often come at a broader cost to global trade relations and domestic consumers. While they may protect certain industries and improve trade balances temporarily, the long-term consequences can include economic isolation, inefficiency, and a global slowdown. Ultimately, these policies often backfire, especially when they provoke retaliatory measures and disrupt the interconnected global economy.

Sharing is caring!