Home   »   UPSC Mains Essay Analysis 2024   »   UPSC Essay 2024 Question 7

All ideas having large consequences are always simple

7. All ideas having large consequences are always simple

Approach 

  • Introduce by providing the benefits of simple ideas, followed by meaning and context
  • Philosophical Basis
  • Examples of simple ideas having large, impactful consequences
  • Antithesis: Not all impactful ideas are simple, not all simple ideas have large consequences, risks of oversimplification. 
  • Conclusion

Meaning/ Context

  • Ideas by themselves have no consequences.
    • Only when put to action/implemented, they have consequences. 
  • Why simple ideas? Clear, easy to communicate, broad acceptance→ powerful outcomes.
  • Philosophical Basis: Occam’s Razor by 14th-century philosopher William of Ockham.
  • The simplest explanation or solution, with the fewest assumptions, is often most likely the right one→aligns with the idea that powerful ideas are often characterised by their simplicity.

Relevant Quotes

“The greatest ideas are the simplest.” – William Golding (Novelist)

Historical Examples

  • Invention of wheel-A primitive human’s simple observation of rolling objects led to the invention of the wheel→simple idea, which revolutionised transportation and technology.
  • Gandhi’s simple idea of non-violence (Ahimsa) shaped the Indian freedom struggle

Different Dimensions/ Examples of Simple Ideas with powerful impacts

  • Individual: Simple life-changing ideas, e.g., following a daily routine, which have a powerful impact on well-being and productivity of an individual.
  • Societal: Ideas like the Golden Rule– “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you” have driven human behaviour (empathy, compassion, fairness, respect) since time immemorial.
  • Political: Ideas like democracy, which says that power rests with the people, and that every individual has the right to determine how they are governed.
    • The simplicity of democracy’s foundational idea made it adaptable to various cultures and political environments and has influenced the structure of governments worldwide
  • Economic: The basic idea of demand and supply is the cornerstone of economic theory, and governs markets around the world.
  • Governance: Ideas like Rule of law, transparency, simple, streamlined regulations→ forms the basis of governance.
    • E.g., the implementation of GST simplified the complex taxation system by replacing multiple indirect taxes with a single tax structure→made compliance easier for businesses, increased tax collection due to better transparency and streamlined processes. 
  • International Relations: peace through diplomacy, free trade, mutual cooperation→ core of modern international relations. 
    • E.g., Quad (Quadrilateral Security Dialogue), comprising the U.S., India, Japan, and Australia is based on the fundamental idea of mutual cooperation, and aims at open, stable and prosperous Indo-Pacific.
  • Environment: The simple idea of sustainability (wise use of resources) has been driving all major global environmental initiatives.
    • E.g., Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), UN High Seas Treaty
  • Science: Laws of Motion→These basic ideas in physics have helped us make machines, explore space, and understand the universe.

Anecdote

According to legends, Isaac Newton’s discovery of gravity started with the simple sight of an apple falling from a tree. This everyday occurrence led him to formulate the law of gravity, which changed the course of science

Antithesis

  • Not all impactful ideas are simple→Many complex ideas have had profound impact, especially in the field of science. 
    • For, e.g., quantum theory which has led to the development of many modern devices, including lasers, transistors, light-emitting diodes, and electron microscopes.
  • Not All Simple Ideas Have Large Consequences: There have been many simple ideas that gained popularity for a short time, but they do not always lead to significant or lasting consequences.
    • E.g., toys like fidget spinners→ became a trend for a short period of time but had no lasting impact.
  • Oversimplification can lead to negative consequences→economic or political misinterpretations, and ineffective decision-making. 
    • For e.g., startups that focus solely on the basic principle of demand and supply without considering other important factors such as market competition, customer satisfaction, regulatory frameworks, and operational costs, often fail.

Conclusion

Simple ideas, characterised by their clarity and ease of understanding, have far-reaching impact on individuals, societies, and have driven the course of human history. By appreciating the fact that the true impact of an idea lies in its ability to address the complexities of the world, we can strive to develop ideas that are both profound and impactful. 

Sharing is caring!

About the Author

I, Sakshi Gupta, am a content writer to empower students aiming for UPSC, PSC, and other competitive exams. My objective is to provide clear, concise, and informative content that caters to your exam preparation needs. I strive to make my content not only informative but also engaging, keeping you motivated throughout your journey!

TOPICS:

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *